45 single, Side A. Challenge (59274) (1964)
Track listing
Side A
- "If I Can't Have You" (Jeannie Seely, Gail Talley) – 2:35
Side B
- "Old Memories Never Die" (Carl Belew, Clyde Pitts) – 2:20
Background
Before recording her first hit singles for Monument Records and becoming known as "Miss Country Soul," Jeannie Seely spent years developing her talents as both a performer and songwriter. Seely began singing on WMGW's local radio show in Meadville, Pennsylvania, and on a local television show in Erie at age 11. After high school, she worked in banking before relocating to California in the early 1960s to pursue opportunities in the music business. While living in Los Angeles, she worked for Liberty and Imperial Records as a secretary and established herself as a promising songwriter, co-writing "Anyone Who Knows What Love Is (Will Understand)," which became a hit for Irma Thomas. Her songs were also recorded by artists including Connie Smith, Dottie West, and Norma Jean.
Seely's growing reputation as a songwriter led to a recording contract with California-based Challenge Records. She had her first recording session for the label on November 5, 1964, at RCA Studio B in Nashville. Seely embarked on a west coast tour to promote the single, leading to her meeting songwriter Hank Cochran. He encouraged her to move to Nashville to further pursue a country career. She relocated to Nashville in 1965 with little more than a Ford Falcon and $50 in her pocket. Within weeks of arriving, Seely saw Hank Cochran again at the 1965 DJ convention. He agreed to help her with her career if he were allowed to have control of her decisions. She was hired by Porter Wagoner as a featured vocalist on his road show, giving her valuable exposure to country music audiences.
Recording
Audio
Critical reception
Upon its release, Cash Box magazine highlighted "If I Can't Have You" as a promising debut for newcomer Jeannie Seely. In its December 19, 1964 issue, the publication awarded the single a B+ rating and suggested that Seely "can make a national name for herself" with the recording. The review described the song as a "pretty, slow-shufflin' chorus-backed ode." The magazine also reviewed the single's B-side, "Old Memories Never Die," describing it as a "rhythmic tearjerker" and praising Seely's emotionally charged vocal performance. The review characterized the recording as a heartfelt reflection on a failed romance.
Cash Box review, December 19, 1964.
Personnel
- Joe Johnson – producer
- Jeannie Seely – lead vocals